The developer’s claim that it would be a ‘net zero mine’ is legally flawed, according to the ruling.
ADVERTISEMENTThe UK’s first new coal mine in three decades will not go ahead following a decision in the high court.
Friday’s ruling is a significant victory for climate groups, who challenged the project's claim it would have zero impact on global emissions.
High Court Justice David Holgate's decision follows a June ruling by the UK Supreme Court that said planners reviewing oil well-drilling permits must consider the greenhouse gas emissions from burning the extracted oil.
“The assumption that the proposed mine would not produce a net increase in greenhouse gas emissions, or would be a net zero mine, is legally flawed," Holgate said.
Climate campaigners celebrate a ‘huge victory’
Friends of the Earth and South Lakes Action on Climate Change, a local group, challenged the government’s approval of the plan for the mine’s development in a coastal town in England’s northwest Cumbria area.
The developer, West Cumbria Mining, defended the proposal in court after the Labour government, which was elected to power in July, dropped its support for the project approved by their Conservative predecessors.
“This is fantastic news and a huge victory for our environment and everyone who has fought against this climate-damaging and completely unnecessary coal mine," said attorney Niall Toru of Friends of the Earth.
“The case against it is overwhelming: it would have huge climate impacts, its coal isn’t needed and it harms the UK’s international reputation on climate."
The ruling sends the decision back to the government for reconsideration.
What is next for the Cumbria coal mine plan?
The mining company, which had promoted the project as a net-zero positive, said it would consider the ruling but declined to comment.
When the Conservatives approved the plan in 2022, critics said it was a backward step and would make it harder to achieve a goal of generating 100 per cent of electricity from clean energy sources by 2035 and reaching net-zero carbon emissions by 2050.
The left-leaning Labour government has also distanced itself from its predecessor's emphasis on oil and gas exploration.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer has announced plans to increase wind power generation and pledged to not issue new oil drilling licenses in the North Sea.
The mine on the site of a shuttered chemical plant in Whitehaven would have extracted coking coal used in steelmaking rather than producing electricity.
Opponents said the coal would no longer be needed domestically as Britain's largest steelmaking operation in Port Talbot, Wales, owned by India’s Tata Steel, transitions from coal-fired blast furnaces to electric arc furnaces, which emit less carbon.
